|
Thai Girlfriend, Real Job, Fake University StudentNote: Names have been changed to protect the identity of individuals and businesses. (Notably, the victim of this case posted several messages on a public internet messageboard in a discussion he started detailing this case further from his perspective, for the general public, using his real name.) This case study is one of a Thai girlfriend with a "bad girl result", even though it actually falls into the "missing person" class of cases. It has many elements all in one case:
Thailand Private Investigations received an inquiry to find a "missing person". The man, William, was a 30 year old Singapore professional looking for a young Thai lady, Noy, who he had known for 2 years and who was scheduled to graduate from Ramkamhaeng University, according to her communications. Major: Hotel Management. William and Noy had planned to spend two weeks together at the end of December, but William had suddenly lost all contact with Noy in mid-October, receiving no replies in email and getting only voice mail on the mobile phone from that point onward. She said she would graduate in February. William was worried sick that Noy had been in an accident (such as on a motorcycle), and was planning to come to Bangkok to find her but couldn't do the search trip at that particular time. He realized that he would need some reliable Thai help anyway (given language and general Thailand familiarity issues), and decided to engage the services of a skilled private investigator. The case started as a missing person case, not discreet at all. It initially appeared that Noy might possibly have had an accident, based on the limited amount of information William initially gave us (he was very cautious and private). However, the case was challenging in that William's information on Noy was short on specific location information. The more we asked, we got just more drama back, no useful details. William made clear that she was not a bar girl but was a respectable lady, and seemed embarrassed to be using a private investigator. Here was what the facts boiled down to:
William was a fairly handsome, cheerful, well dressed and pretty conservative guy with a big heart. Noy's photo revealed a fairly normal looking mainstream Thai lady who was pretty and had a somewhat elegant and charming expression. Noy was from the middle class, according to her story to William. After spending some friendly time with her at the hotel two years previous, they had started exchanging email and William would call her periodically. Noy's English was fairly good and improving. William never had sex with Noy, and did not even try, though their emails became love letters. Noy had been shy when she first met William (but had given him her phone number), and had asked William to "wait" for her. William was convinced that Noy was a proper Thai lady. William had brought his mother and father to Thailand specifically to meet Noy a year previous to the investigation, though Noy had been reluctant to meet them at that time. Noy did not ask for money. After nearly a year of regular emailing, William had started sending money because he wanted to help Noy, as Noy had alluded to her financial pressures. At this point, William did not tell us the amounts. The case started as a non-discreet missing person case, and the first two approaches were the hotel where she worked and the university she attended. To stay on the safe side, we started off somewhat discreetly, "safety first". Even though at this point it was not a discreet case, experience told us that if it was a scam, we didn't want to take any unnecessary risks at tipping off the subject whereby they could start to create false trails or a cover story, e.g., "she died in a motorcycle accident". Passthru surveillance at the hotel did not turn up Noy. Phoning the hotel revealed she didn't work there anymore. Phoning up to the hotel's Human Resources Department for details, the agent found out that Noy had quit the hotel almost a year before. Noy had not told this to William, who thought she still worked there. Indeed, Noy had just no-showed at work one day after picking up her last paycheck, rather than give notice, and the hotel had been unhappy about that. That was our first indication that Noy may have a pattern of just disappearing, inconsiderate of others. Walking back into Noy's old hotel environment with the knowledge that Noy was nowhere around, the agent tried a social method to try to get any clues from any former coworkers who might know something significant. the agent posed as a Ramkamhaeng student looking for her friend Noy, but found out that Noy didn't really mix much with her co-workers, there had been some turnover among Noy's coworkers since then, and nobody who was still there had any idea where Noy went. There were some new workers in Noy's department who hadn't been there long enough to even know who Noy was. It was a dead end socially. The hotel (and later, other sources) had a Bangkok home address for Noy on Ramkamhaeng soi 39, which we checked out later, but Noy had moved out long before, with no forwarding address. The next lead was Ramkamhaeng University. First, we could not find any record of Noy's Thai name on any graduation list. In fact, there was no record of Noy's recent attendance at Ramkamhaeng University! It appeared that she had just dropped out of her studies more than a year earlier, contrary to what she had been telling William all this time. William's response to all this was initially one of shock and denial, even disbelief. That eventually switched to feelings of betrayal and rage. At this point, William started to tell us some interesting things, which he should have told us before. She had dropped contact with him immediately after he sent her some more money. At that time, he didn't have the money to send, and had asked her if she could wait until his paycheck later that month, but in an unusual event she hurried him, saying that she must have it by a specific date, and it absolutely could not be later than that. He met the deadline, and didn't hear from her after that. There are a lot of things that people don't tell us because they are embarrassed. William had been sending a lot of money by Thai student standards, far more than was necessary to study fulltime at Ramkamhaeng University and not need to work at all. William was generous by Thai standards, but William was also both working and going to school at the same time, and he constantly told Noy this, that he could not send more money, that he could send money when he received a paycheck, and so on. Noy was receiving from William more than 3 times the comfortable amount required for a Thai student in fulltime attendance at Ramkamhaeng University, i.e., students who do not need to work. It was more than 5 times the subsistence student amount. At one point, William gave Noy a portable computer. It was a lot of money, but Noy and William had discussed it. William planned it carefully, painstakingly loaded the Thai version of Windows and put the Thai characters on the keyboard (being that he bought it in Singapore so no Thai keyboard on a laptop PC). William bought some things for Noy, and observed that Noy used only the finest and expensive brand name accessories. It was the only sensitive matter to William, as he didn't spend money on such things, but he loved her and thought that she was a quality lady, and wished to show that he wanted the best for her. By his own admission, he missed a warning sign there. There was other information, too, which was basically some progressively emerging pressures to send ever more money to help Noy's family's needs. Eventually, we reassessed the case, and decided to switch the case to a fully discreet case. It was still a missing person case, but we did not want to risk that she or anyone else would find out about an investigation and mislead it by proxies. We had no current address on record, though we found out where her family was generally located in Chiang Mai province. Since she had been living in Bangkok for years, we first started to pursue Noy on the ground in Bangkok, using a female Thai agent who had attended Ramkamhaeng University, knew the area, and was employing a standard method for a case of this type. To make a long story short, our agent found out that Noy had left a cold trail with most of her old acquaintances. Noy had borrowed money from some other people and owed them, which probably explained some of it -- hiding from creditors. However, Noy had basically just moved suddenly, with no advance notice to friends and associates, indeed had just disappeared as regards most of her old acquaintances ... and her trail was about a year cold. These were genuine responses from the sources, and they all pointed to the hotel she had truly worked for. One day, Noy just moved without discussion. Nonetheless, moving from lead to lead, the agent eventually found out about an acquaintance from that time period who had also worked at the hotel where William had met Noy but no longer worked there, so we would not have encountered them at the hotel before. That friend turned out to seem a bit dodgy herself, but the agent, posing as a simple old friend from Ramkamhaeng, found out Noy's subsequent step after the hotel job. The friend had not spoken to Noy for many months, and looked the agent in the eye in some brief intense ways when asking some questions about how she knew Noy (answer: from previous residence). (The cover story was simple. In investigations, cover stories and agents are usually simple, not too tricky, which gives us more flexibility in adapting.) In short order, her friend capitulated in this face to face, Thai style encounter when put on the spot (notably, phone calls would in many cases not get this info, only face to face, on the spot), responding: Noy had moved to a job with an even more luxurious hotel almost a year before (which she didn't tell William, where she was really working), one of the newest and very best in Bangkok for foreign businessmen and wealthy tourists, and part of an international chain. For this hotel, she worked the lobby greeting guests and also served in the lounge. It seemed fairly clear that Noy's friend had not talked to Noy in quite some time. The Thai lady agent's "sixth sense" about Noy's friend was that this friend had a pretty intimate relationship with Noy in the past, and was seasoned with Noy about something or the other, but Noy and this friend had fallen out of contact with each other, and this friend really didn't know how to reach Noy or Noy's current situation. Our agent immediately changed clothes into somewhat less casual and more classy dress and dashed off to this hotel quickly (to minimize the chances that Noy's friend could find some channel to contact Noy in the mean time, though the previous encounter seemed benign enough). Again, thorough passthru surveillance did not find Noy. A phone inquiry for Noy revealed she did not work there currently. Then the agent phoned up to the Human Resources Department, and the initial reaction was "if you find her, tell us!" They were looking for Noy, too. Noy had quit there suddenly without any notice, and not returned some items to the hotel. By "quit", she just didn't show up one day when they expected her, and had disappeared. The hotel had been unable to reach her on the mobile phone, their only valid point of contact. (Again, obsolete Ramkamhaeng 39 address.) The date of disappearance was also mid-October, which was when William had made his last payment on her deadline. We were contemplating how to approach co-workers at this hotel for information, as we had closed in to less than 3 months of Noy. The agent sat in the lobby lounge and watched things for awhile, especially the other lobby ladies. On the phone, the agent discussed with our other office agents various tactics we could do quickly, such as whether to approach Noy's former co-workers while she was still there, posing as a Ramkamhaeng friend. Another option might be to bring in a second, expat agent as a well dressed expat apparent businessman, just to probe their reaction to see which employee(s) might know Noy. In private investigations, there are many instances where you must make split second decisions. However, there are also times when you should decide to not take unnecessary risks, especially in discreet investigations, and should back off rather than take a risk. Cutting corners can blow a case and result in a failed "Sorry, we tried"... and in this case, we decided to wait until another day. One of the factors we considered was another, parallel investigative trail that our staff had been pursuing and which had started to pan out. To make another long story short, at about this time we had some results on Noy's family. This led us to some family contact options. At this point, we had no idea whether Noy was a renegade daughter from a respectable family (we see lots of those in the new generation), or a "family business" of scamming foreigners (we see lots of those, too). However, one thing was for sure: William was not concerned about being discreet any more, as his relationship with Noy was over, but William did want to know what happened. As we told William, we were staying discreet in order to find out the truth as he requested, not get a staged reaction to cover up the truth. We decided to approach a particular sister working for a company in Bangkok. Posing as a friend from Ramkamhaeng University, we got instant results. Noy's sister was not tricky but seemed quite innocent, and told us Noy's recent history. It is highly probable that Noy's family had no idea what Noy had done, and may have been dismayed if they had known. From Noy's sister, we found out that: Noy had flown to the USA in mid-October with an American boyfriend she had met at the new hotel, flying out apparently very near the deadline day she had rushed William to wire his last money. She was still in the U.S. and we got the U.S. telephone number from her sister. I must give William a lot of credit for handling this well. Initially, he had been understandably enraged due to the trickery and betrayal of his lover. However, by this point in time, as the story had already unfolded over several days -- the initial false statements regarding university attendance & graduation, and Noy's work history, William had calmed down and gotten past his denial and rage. We had spent a lot of time talking with William on the phone, and had become friends. As a mature individual, William had come to terms with the reality that there is nothing you can realistically do after the fact in a situation like this, and animosity hurts yourself, so sometimes you've just gotta turn it into a life experience to learn from. There have been worse situations ... William just wondered if Noy had much compassion for him. Of course, I had seen enough of Noy's history with people to think Noy probably had little compassion for others, and was very selfish and greedy, so I tried to prepare William to expect that. It was clear that William had grown up in a protected environment with good trustworthy parents, and in Singaporean society people are relatively cooperative, ethical, and considerate. William needed to learn more about the wide variety of people out in the world beyond his microcosm. In the end, William decided not to call her nor disturb her current relationship. Before reaching that decision, as there was no rush, he backed off and took lots more time to calm down and think things through, his next step, if any. He didn't want to do anything bad, too, to get back at Noy. He didn't want to become that kind of person. He didn't even want her phone number in the US, which we had ready to give him. He eventually decided that he really just wanted to let go, and take it as a valuable learning experience about life. After that, he said he just sent her an email message politely revealing to her that he knew the truth, and expressing the hope that in the future she becomes a more spiritually considerate kind of person in her future life. He said that he will forgive her for her past, but that of course he will find another wife because he had found Noy to not be a trustworthy person. He hoped that Noy would respond by email, but Noy never did. Since Noy's mailbox on a well known service did not fill up with mail nor subsequently expire, it is highly probable that she received the message but simply did not reply. For all he had done for her, she did not even give a "sorry" or "thank you". On the other hand, William was very thankful to us. William was awed about how much money he had lost which he could have invested otherwise into his future, and wondered whether much of that money had just gone into a lady's wasteful spending and expensive lifestyle all this time instead of to her family. William was embarrassed to reveal the truth to his family and friends, though he did, and in fact posted his experience on the Internet. At least he made it into a learning experience. It's good that William didn't get lured down the dark roads of either retaliation or trying to save anything about their relationship in some sort of extended fantasy. Bad people are extremely numerous, just drops in the ocean in the world, and typically people won't change, it's just who and what they are in their lives. You typically won't save them or any good relationship, but you can save yourself. Best to just let go and move on, and not get lured out by their karma. There is no insurance for the result of such a relationship after the fact. If he had just contacted me while the relationship was still ongoing and discussed all his experiences up to that point, then I could have given him some objective friendly analysis and advice, and we could have checked out Noy while she was still in Bangkok, including her alleged employment, watching her, and maybe some other things.
The above case was a relatively difficult case to solve because we had so little information to start with, and the lady was apparently hiding from creditors, too -- debts to former friends and associates. The total time taken was several days, and things slowed down after it turned discreet and required things like slow, careful passthru surveillance and some careful social interactions and preparations. Many cases are not this difficult. We want to emphasize that most ladies who say they are Thai students are truly Thai students and not pulling tricks like the above. Some real university students still trick guys. It is unfortunate that bad girls can result in internet stories to make foreigners more suspicious about, and reluctant to help, truly good students. It is best to give people the benefit of the doubt, especially if they seem reasonable. However, if your Thai student girlfriend starts to pressure you to significantly increase the monthly payments with stories that seem a little odd, or if other things in her behavior seem suspicious, then you may want to consider verifying the information discreetly before sending a lot more money and investing a lot more of your time and heart. Notably, both hotels might have terminated Noy's employment if they knew what she was doing. It is official hotel policy in many top class hotels that employees are discouraged from engaging in relationships with clients -- the official policy of the top management. How well each hotel is managed, in various departments, is another matter. We've had some other cases of men who dated a hotel employee who they met at the hotel. Some have been very careful to keep it a secret from others at the hotel. In reality, many hotels' employees do this kind of thing secretly and fairly routinely on their own. Some hotel employees have even given introductions to another lady, as a facilitator in trying to line up a foreigner with a wannabe Thai girlfriend. If you find a girlfriend referral operation in a hotel, just watch the employees' behavior during their operation. Sometimes, they are clearly keeping this secret from certain higher ups in the hotel, as they may clearly request the relationship be kept discreet. If a hotel hires friends and relatives of existing employees in order to create a smoother and more stable employee community, then there is an increased likelihood of this kind of conspiracy operation occurring at lower levels. Sometimes, they're really looking for a husband for a relative, and there is nothing wrong with that. On the other hand, sometimes they're just looking for another revenue stream in a tricky way. It can be very lucrative. Many ladies who work at a hotel and develop a relationship with a hotel customer are truly sincere, not promiscuous (either not promiscuous at all, or not too much for a client's value system), and not mainly just out for the guy's money. However, some ladies seek jobs where they have exposure to a lot of people with money, such as sales and service jobs. Many employers don't care, as many pretty and playful ladies reel in business for them, too, or they just don't want to be bothered otherwise. Ladies with a real job are often seen as more legitimate by guys seeking romance and a wife, compared to ladies without a job. Of course, it's no guarantee, it's mainly a matter of statistics. If you see red flags, then it may be best to do some due diligence, and try not to become just a statistic yourself.
Sample case studies of Thai girlfriends:
Introducing your optional expat PI - Mark
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Our company is located in central Bangkok on Sukhumvit soi 2, within walking distance of the skytrain, between the Ploenchit and Nana stations.
Thailand Private Investigations,
Lucky Lion Pride Co., Ltd. |
By appointment only, please.
Email: inbox at our domain name. Old customers please note: We moved our office from Pakkred, Nonthaburi to the city center. Please do not go out to our old office in Pakkred, on Bond Street. We are no longer there. New customers introduction: We are a close knit group of family and trusted friends who take pride in our work. |
Our office is co-located with Export Quality Services Co., Ltd., aka EQ, which is the same company we previously operated under, but we split off the private investigations business to a daughter company, Lucky Lion Pride Co., Ltd., whereby EQ now focuses on language translation and some other things.
Mobile Tel.: +66-80-062-4243 or 080-062-4243 (native English speaker) -- call ANYTIME, 24/7 (I turn off my phone volume when asleep)
If you want to chat via LINE / WhatsApp, please add the phone number above to your phone's contacts, and it should automatically add me to your LINE and WhatsApp shortly after that.
For expediting in LINE, my LINE ID is alphalion (alpha lion with no space between the words).
 |
|||||||||
| www.ThailandPI.com |  |
Home | People Finder | Thai Lady | SiteMap | DNA Test | About us | Contact us | |
Menu:
Site Map
This website is about
Thailand Private
Investigations
Site Map
The Site Map
is also the
center tab
on the menu
on the top
and bottom
of every page.